Notre-Dame de Paris as seen from the east, looking at the flying buttresses.

Five Churches That Made Gothic

Gothic is a building system of three elements: the pointed arch, the rib vault and the flying buttress. Between 1080 and 1200 they come together, and when they do, a church can suddenly be built taller, with thinner walls and more light than ever before. To see the three techniques arrive one by one, you only need to visit five churches that made Gothic.

Do you need a car to visit these cathedrals

If you rent a car via SunnyCars, the price is clear upfront. Insurance included. No counter games, no surprise fees.

LUX earns a small commission. You don’t pay extra.

1. Cluny III: the pointed arch

Cluny III, built between 1088 and 1130, was the largest church in Western Christendom until St. Peter’s in Rome overtook it. Length 187 metres. Vault height 33 metres. Romanesque at its most extreme. And exactly there sits the invention that made Gothic possible: the pointed arch.

A round arch pushes in two directions: down and sideways. A pointed arch pushes mostly down. That lets a builder go higher without the walls giving way first. Cluny used the pointed arch for one practical reason: the builders could not otherwise have kept their own church standing. Gothic inherited the principle and built a whole style on it.*

Cluny today is one transept arm. The rest was quarried for stone after the French Revolution. What remains is enough to understand what once stood here.

The interior of Cluny abbey church
Cluny Abbey church. Cluny used the pointed arch for one practical reason: the builders could not otherwise have kept their own church standing. Photo: Canva
The tower of what is left of the Cluny abbey, seen through a gate.
Cluny Abbey. Cluny today is one transept arm. Photo: Canva

2. Durham: the rib vault

Durham Cathedral, begun in 1093 and largely finished by 1133, sits on a sandstone rock above the River Wear. From the outside, a Norman fortress. From the inside, something more interesting. Here, for the first time in a large church, a systematic rib vault runs across the main nave.

Looking through the trees, you can see Durham Cathedral on a hill
Durham Cathedral is build on a hill. Photo: Creative Commons
The rib vault ceiling of Durham cathedral
Durham Cathedral features the earliest surviving example of a pointed rib vault in England, constructed in the 1090s. This pioneering technique allowed the cathedral to reach unprecedented heights and laid the foundation for future Gothic architecture. Photo: Peter Johannes

A rib vault works like a skeleton. Stone ribs carry the weight and direct the forces down to the piers. The panels between the ribs are kept as light as possible. UNESCO calls the Durham vault a precursor to Gothic. The cathedral itself is still Romanesque, but the logic of the vault is already Gothic.

Durham was not alone. Speyer in Germany, rebuilt from 1080 onward, also used early rib vaults in its aisles. The technique was in the air. Durham did it more systematically, and at greater scale, and that is why Durham gets the credit.

3. Saint-Denis: three techniques in one system

Between 1140 and 1144, Abbot Suger rebuilds the choir of his abbey church at Saint-Denis, just north of Paris. He brings the pointed arch, the rib vault and large glass surfaces together into one coherent design. What in Cluny and Durham were still separate inventions, becomes one system here.

The difference is not only technical. For Suger, light is theology. The more light enters the church, the more tangible God’s presence becomes. The wall is replaced by glass because that brings the worshipper closer to God. The windows are not decoration. They are the point.

Colored rose window in transept (south) of the Saint-Denis cathedral. Perfect Gothic Geometry. Rose windows are a trade mark of gothic architecture.
Rose window in the southern transept of the Saint-Denis cathedral. Photo: Benjamin Gavaudo

Saint-Denis is also political. Since Dagobert (639), it has been the burial site of the French kings. When Suger launches Gothic here, he ties the new style straight to the crown. From day one, Gothic is a royal story.

Beams of light fall into the Gothic cathedral of St. Denis, through the colored stained glass.
The Gothic Saint-Denis cathedral. LUX Church Heritage. Photo: Creative Commons

birth of the gothic rose window

The real birth of the Gothic rose window – that is, a large round window with tracery and glass – occurred around 1140, during the renovation of the abbey church of Saint-Denis near Paris under the direction of abt Suger.

He had a pioneering circular window installed in the west facade, reinforced with wrought-iron rings and filled with colored stained glass. Suger’s motivation was not only aesthetic, but theological: “God is light, ” he wrote.

Through a window, that divine light had to touch the soul. As Pope Benedict XVI beautifully explained: from the outside Gothic windows appear somber, “but once inside they come alive; the light that falls through them reveals all their splendor.” That experience from darkness to radiant light was a conscious lesson in faith: the material glass became a conduit of immaterial, heavenly light.

From then on, the rose window became not an architectural extra, but a core part of the Gothic vocabulary. The rose windows of Laon (c. 1190), Chartres (c. 1215) and later Reims and Paris built on the idea of a circle that not only let light through, but also visualized order, theology and geometry. The oculus had evolved into a rose window: no longer a simple hole in the wall, but a flower of glass, stone and symbolism that gave structure as well as meaning to the entire cathedral.

Stained glass in red, green and blue colors, depicting abbot Suger.
Abbot Suger in window in ambulatory, Abbaye St-Denis, St-Denis, Paris. Photo: Creative Commons

4. Notre-Dame de Paris: flying buttress and scale

Construction of Notre-Dame de Paris begins in 1163, twenty years after Suger’s choir at Saint-Denis. What worked at abbey scale at Saint-Denis is tested here at city scale for the first time: a nave 33 metres high, cutting right through central Paris.

That height is only possible thanks to the third Gothic element: the flying buttress. An external arch that carries the weight of the roof over the side aisle and down to an outer pier. With that in place, the high inner walls can be opened up for glass. When the first flying buttresses of Notre-Dame were actually built is a debate of its own.**

The first completed Gothic cathedral is the one at Sens. Built between 1135 and 1164, finished earlier than Notre-Dame. But what Sens did early, Notre-Dame does at scale. Here Gothic proves itself at the size of a city.

The flying buttresses of the Notre-Dame de Paris.
The flying buttresses of the Notre-Dame de Paris. © Yann Arthus-Bertrand/CORBIS
Sens Cathedral Rose Window
The flamboyant style rose window in the western facade of Sens Cathedral. Photo: Ville de Sens

5. Chartres: the standard

In 1194 the old cathedral of Chartres burns down to its walls. What rises in its place, in barely thirty years, becomes the reference model of High Gothic. Chartres is the first cathedral in which the flying buttress is part of the design from the start. Pointed arch, rib vault and flying buttress work together for the first time straight off the drawing board.

UNESCO calls the unity of architecture, sculpture and stained glass a complete and developed expression of medieval art. Reims, Amiens, Beauvais, Cologne, Westminster and León all then look to Chartres. What Saint-Denis tried, Chartres turned into the standard.

Chartres Cathedral floorplan
Chartres Cathedral floorplan
Chartres Cathedral - Western facade
Chartres Cathedral - Western facade. Photo: Canva

Five churches, one technique per step. Pointed arch at Cluny. Rib vault at Durham. The three together, with light, at Saint-Denis. Flying buttress at city scale at Notre-Dame. The standard at Chartres. To see Gothic at work, start before Notre-Dame. Begin at Cluny and Durham. There, half the building is not yet standing, and everything is already in motion.

* The pointed arch is older than Cluny. It appears earlier in the Islamic architecture of Spain and Sicily, and some researchers trace the line from there to Cluny via Monte Cassino. What Cluny does is apply it systematically in a large Christian church in Western Europe. The invention itself is older.

** The dating of the original flying buttresses of Notre-Dame de Paris is disputed. They were long assumed to date from before 1180, which would place them among the very earliest. More recent work, including by Caroline Bruzelius, places the first flying buttresses later, possibly only at a renovation around 1220. Best treated as an early example of the system, possibly not the first one.

Read more:

my favorite books on cathedrals

Scroll to Top